BIRN Serbia holds debates on media financing

The biggest issue local media in Serbia are facing is a lack of knowledge about project financing and lack of budgetary transparency in allocating money to media outlets, two debates held by BIRN Serbia in Nis and Kragujevac heard. Media representatives said they hoped that some of the problems would be resolved by full implementation of new Media and Public Information Law.  

The debates gathered more than 40 participants including representatives of local media, local government, professional associations and experts.

Media financing through the state budget has so far been implemented in two ways: most of the funds were distributed directly (through public procurement procedures, directly from the budget or through direct contracting), while smaller amount of funds were distributed through open calls for content production.

The new media regulations prescribe significant changes and introduce new practices in budgetary financing of media content under which open-call procedures are the only legal way of financing.

BIRN Serbia presented an analysis of the current practices of open-call procedures, clearly earmarking potential pitfalls: lack of standards and criteria, lack of programme quality and lack of broadcasting possibility. The same analysis will be presented later in Novi Sad, Novi Pazar and Belgrade.

The debates are organised within the project ‘Enhancing media independence through development of sustainable and competitive financing model’, supported by the MATRA programme of the embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands.  

Prison Terms Bring Close to Kidnapping Case

Four men were sentenced to prison terms on September 18 for their role in a kidnapping of a woman in a case that BIRN Kosovo reported on even before Kosovo’s prosecutors did.

Justice in Kosovo

“Justice in Kosovo” broadcast two TV programmes on March 30 and April 6 about the kidnapping.

After the programmes were shown, the prosecution opened a case against Ilir Kuqishta, who was accused of kidnapping his ex-wife with three other men, who were accused of helping him.

On September 18, the Basic Court of Ferizaj sentenced the four men to prison terms for offenses including kidnapping, aiding in a kidnapping and illegal gun possession.

Kuqishta was sentenced to four years in prison for breaking into the home of his ex-wife and kidnapping her on November 22, 2013.

He was helped by Jakup Ramadani, Samet Arifi and Afrim Arifi., who were sentenced to four months in prison for helping Kuqishta.

Gjergj Erebara

Gjergj Erebara is journalist for the Balkan Investigative Reporting Network, BIRN, in Albania.

Since 1998 he has worked as a journalist for various print publications, electronic media and televisions. He has a bachelor degree in Journalism and Master of Science degree in Economic History from University of Lund.

Money Luring Kosovars to Fight in Syria and Iraq, Xharra Said

Money is a big driver in getting Kosovars to join Islamic militant groups such as an ISIS fighting in Syria and Iraq, Jeta Xharra, the director of BIRN Kosovo, told the Los Angeles Times recently.

Jeta Xharra“Much of this has nothing to do with ideology,” Xharra said in an September 9 article. “Rather, money. All authorities have to do to track ISIS’ foreign recruits is to follow the money trail.”

Xharra also analyzed the recent arrests of 40 people in Kosovo who were suspected of fighting in Syria with militant groups Islamic State and Al Nusra Front.

“More than half of them were released because they had no idea what they were getting into,” Xharra said. “Many new recruits do not know either. They are just replying to Internet ads that are pouring in from Turkey, promising money in exchange for a year of adventure, like a gap year after college.”

With widespread poverty and high unemployment, Xharra warned that more Muslims across the Balkans could be lured by Islamist militants.

BIRN Film Premieres in Kosovo’s Divided Mitrovica

The screening of BIRN’s road-movie documentary The Majority Starts Here in Mitrovica was followed by a debate examining how transitional justice can address the grievances of the wartime past.

The BIRN film about young people’s interpretations of the recent conflict in the former Yugoslavia was shown for the first time in the north Kosovo town on Monday, followed by a discussion on the issues raised by the documentary, entitled ‘Why Do We Need Transitional Justice?’

The event, organised by the EU Rule-of-Law Mission in Kosovo, EULEX, and the Centre for Peace and Tolerance, brought together representatives of civil society, journalists and the international community to examine what role the judicial process should play in post-war reconciliation.

BIRN journalist Marija Ristic, who was a screenwriter for the documentary, said that the film showed that young people in former Yugoslav countries are poorly informed about the recent conflicts, which happened while they were still children.

“The majority of them knew something about the war in their own country, but very few of them knew the scale of conflicts that took place in their neighbouring countries, and this is what we wanted to change with our documentary,” Ristic said.

“It is hard to show the history of one war in an hour-long documentary, but our message was that even though people still have different opinions about the war, they should sit and talk about that. We have to understand that reconciliation is a process,” she added.

EULEX judge Paulo Teixeira, who worked as a war crime judge in East Timor before coming to Kosovo, said that his long career in the field had taught him that solving post-war issues takes time.

“Things should not be forgotten, but forgiven. War crimes are universal, they take place everywhere… but the difference is not in the war crime itself, but in the way how people deal with that after the war,” Teixeira told the discussion.

Asja Zujo, who worked as a legal officer in Bosnia and Herzegovina and is now with EULEX, said that almost 20 years after the Dayton Agreement that ended the Bosnian war, the process was not over.

“A lot has been done, but there is still space for improvement. War crime trials cannot be the only way of dealing with the past, we have to work on other things as well, such as missing persons, refugees,” Zujo said.

“We still need to rebuild institutions and that remains a problem,” she added.

Alan Edwards from EULEX police also spoke about his experience in conflict zones in Northern Ireland and Cyprus.

“It is very difficult in a post-conflict situation to be fair to both sides in the conflict. But it is important to keep trying. Change takes a lot of time,” Edwards said.

The Majority Starts Here follows six young people from the former Yugoslavia who make a journey through the region, examining how the conflicts of the past, which they were too young to understand fully at the time, have influenced both their present and their prospects for the future.

It was produced by BIRN and directed by award-winning film-maker Lode Desmet, and is part of BIRN’s Balkan Transitional Justice project, which aims to improve public understanding of transitional justice issues in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Kosovo, Macedonia, Montenegro and Serbia.

Debate on Environment and Energy in the Republic of Kosovo

On May 29, 2014 “Life in Kosovo” held a debate on environment and energy in the Republic of Kosovo.

Panellists for this debate were: from AKR: Sabit Rastelica, Azra Krasniqi and Fadil Ismajli; from AAK: Magbule Shkodra, Ardian Gjini and Laura Kryeziu; from PDK: Blerim Rexha, Laura Zherka dhe Gani Koci; LDK: Teuta Sahatçija dhe Besa Gaxherri; Vetëvendosje: Agron Dida, Lumnije Morina and Faruk Mujka; and NISMA: Izet Ibrahimi  and Petrit Gashi.

Main issues discussed during this debate included the issue of what would be the amount of MW produced of renewable energy in order to fulfill citizens’ needs by the end of 2020. Based on this concern, candidates for MPs gave their party program on energy: AKR promised that by the end of 2020 the Hydro central in Zhur will produce 128 MW capacity from water recourses while at the end the amount of energy produced will be 640 GW/h, covering 10 percent of Kosovo population.

On the other side AAK said that their hope is in fostering cooperation with Albania, saying that bids for HC in Zhur will be open but this is not their priority since AAK will be more focused on empowering economy; thus help around two thousand hundred households with isolation system. PDK promised that by the end of 2020 around 410 MW will be produced spread in 28 other smaller Hydro Energy projects, where around 700 million Euros will be invested generating 5,500 working places. LDK said that the project in Zhuri will end by the end of 2018 covering 20% of energy produced while the other part will be covered by smaller HC.  Self-Determination Movement emphasized that 50% or renewable energy will come by combining energy systems of Albania and Kosovo.  Similar to other party programs, NISMA  sees the future of energy by finishing the project in Zhuri by the end of 2020, saying that this HC will produce 303MW ; building of 20 mini HC with the capacity of 104 – 200 mw and  usage of urban  waist 0.8-2MW.

The other part of debate was more concentrated in the environmental issues varying from water supply, pollution from old thermo centrals; gravel royalties etc.

Debate on Economy

On June 02, 2014, “Life in Kosovo” held a debate on the economy of the Republic of Kosovo. 

Political party representatives present at the Economy debate were as follows: from AAK: Fehmi Fetahu, Vasilika Zotaj and Shkelzen Jusaj; AKR was represented by: bernard Nikaj, Vileta Gashi and Avni Gashi; PDK: Ramiz Kelmendi, Blerand Stavileci and Margarita Kadriu; LDK: Hykmete Bajrami and Lutfi Zharku; LVV: Dardan Sejdiu, Aida Derguti and Bashkim Nurboja. From Partia e Forte present were: Birol Urcan, Zana Elshani Mullaademi and Valon Badivuku.

LDK member, Mrs. Bajrami made some allegations towards party in power saying that “PDK has not shown that with what criteria will distribute these funds. To get a grant to the Ministry of Agriculture, people from the municipality of Peja paid 500 Euros to make a business plan, and have never seen a list of who received those grants, and those who have never done business plan did not receive grants. ”

AKR representative Mr. Nikaj said that “No agricultural product produced in Kosovo is not freed from taxation agreement with Turkey, for at least 10 years of leather industry is protected, wood processing and all other industries that have the potential to be produced in Kosovo”. Same as Mrs. Bajrami from LDK, Mr. Sejdiu of LVV made allegations towards the party in power by saying that: “To create 137 jobs per day it means that for four years in a row Kosovo should build a factory each day. We have already seen these factories for the last 15 years”.

Debate on Local Products Development

On June 03, 2014 “Life in Kosovo” held a debate on local products development.

Present at this debate were: from AKR – Artan Haziri, Myzejene Selmani, Arbnor Pula;  AAK – Blerim Kuçi, Jeta Rafuna – Hasani, Smajl Latifi; PDK – Blerand Stavileci, Sabedin Kadriu; LDK – Florije Ibishi – Rudniku, Zef Morina, Ardita Rizvanolli; LVV – Dardan Sejdiu, Albana Fetoshi, Salih Salihu; and NISMA – Afërdita Gjonbalaj – Stublla, Milazim Xani, Shukrie Bytyçi.

When asked how will the state support youngsters that are pioneering in the sphere of Internet Technology, party members answered: NISMA: We will give the opportunity to all the young men and women who work on this sphere by helping to digitize the last village with the last technology. We will support each family by offering Internet for free.“

Moreover LVV said that: Kosovo has the most number per capita of engineers for maintenance of networks in Europe and this potential should be used. So, how do I use this potential?-By enabling companies to provide subcontract services to large companies who will also be freed from income tax so that they can reinvest in technology and thus be competitive”. LDK representative highlighted that: “With the increasing quality of education we will train new generations to use computerization system because every enterprise is now digitized and this must be shown. The procurement system, with new generations who know better to use information systems, procurement will be done with electronically tenders”.

Blerand Stavileci from PDK promised that if they rule with the government, during the next mandate “cherry on top” will be establishment of the Ministry of Information and Technology. Other topics related to development of local production included the promises that varied a little from one party program to the other, concentrated mainly in the lowering the fuel prices for agronomy; increased support for local agronomy etc.

Development Fund

On May 01, 2014, “Life in Kosovo” held a debate on promises made about a development fund.

Even though Minister of Finance Besim Beqaj confirmed his presence in the debate, two minutes before the debate a message was sent by Gezim Baxhaku, minister’s advisor, saying that he cannot come.

In absence of Minister Beqaj, “Life in Kosovo” held a debate with: Hykmete Bajrami, MP of LDK; Besnik Bislimi, from Vetevendosje; and Agim Sahiti, a farmer in Kosovo.

This attitude did not surprise the other participants in the debate and they said that the main reason Beqaj did not attend the debate was that he does not have enough facts to defend the “fund”.

Hykmete Bajrami, MP of LDK, who was also part of the debate, said that the failure of minister Beqaj to attend the debate shows that the government is not so interested to support this fund.

According to the other panelist, Besnik Bislimi from Vetevendosje, if the fund had been well-intentioned, Beqaj would immediately come to receive the credits/merits.

MP Hykmete Bajrami also said that the prime minister keeps talking about the development fund, but he has never explained which the criteria for the businesses to apply.

“In the beginning the prime minister said that the fund will be 1 billion Euros, and then he said that the fund will be 1.5 billion Euros, and just recently he raised it again and said that it will be 2 billion euros. We do not even know what is this fund about and the criteria to apply”, Bajrami said.

Farmer Agim Sahiti, also invited in the debate, who has a poultry farm, said that firstly some requirements must be fulfilled and that money should be for business development.

“I use 40 liters of fuel per hour and when there isn’t electricity for 10 hours I use 400 liters, which costs 500 Euros. Therefore, I have higher costs than the businesses that do not lack electricity”, Sahiti said.

Moreover, Besnik Bislimi added that there are some inspectors of the Ministry of Agriculture that give grants for people who do not even have agricultural land; whereas the farmer Sahiti told Bislimi that what he heard is not true.

Debts of Municipalities

On March 27, 2014, “Life in Kosovo” discussed the debts of municipalities, which run in the millions. After the debate “Life in Kosovo” broadcast an investigative report on academic advancement at the University of Prishtina.

 

What is happening with the inherited debts of municipalities? Why did these debts accumulate? What do the current and the previous local governments say?

To discuss about these issues, “Life in Kosovo” invited: Gazmend Muhaxheri, Mayor of Peja, and Ali Berisha, former mayor of Peja.

The mayor of Peja, Gazmend Muhaxheri, said that he is having problems to implement the projects that he planned because the municipality has many unpaid debts.Muhaxheri inherited a debt of 2 million Euros. During the debate he said that majority of debts were accumulated during the election campaign.

In addition, Ali Berisha, said that it is not true that the Municipality of Peja owes a debt of 2 million Euros.

“Peja is in a better condition if we compare it to other municipalities in relation to debts”, Berisha said.

Meanwhile there are other mayors that are asking from the government to pay the debts of their municipalities.

After the debate “Life in Kosovo broadcast a report on academic advancement at the University of Prishtina. The report is about the advancement of five deans in different faculties.