BIRN Albania Unveils Monitoring Report on Transparency and Accessibility in Health and Education

On December 10, BIRN Albania launched the monitoring report, “Transparency and Accessibility in the Health and Education Systems,” during a roundtable event in Tirana.

The event, organized in partnership with Together for Life, Qëndresa Qytetare, and Destiny Center for Excellence under the European Union-funded SPACE project, highlighted the urgent need for improved transparency and inclusivity in Albania’s health and education sectors.

This report provides a comprehensive evaluation of transparency and accessibility in eight public institutions, including regional health and education directorates. It identifies critical gaps in information availability, institutional accountability, and the inclusion of vulnerable groups, offering actionable recommendations to address these challenges.

Kristina Voko, Executive Director of BIRN Albania, emphasized the significance of the report during her opening remarks: “This publication serves as a vital tool for civil society and policymakers, shedding light on systemic issues while paving the way for reforms that can strengthen public trust and service quality.”

Key findings, presented by Ardita Shehaj, an expert in transparency programs, and Aida Myftaraj from ACER, revealed disparities in proactive transparency and FOI responsiveness across institutions.

The panel also featured Suela Lala, an activist for the rights of people with disabilities, Romina Sefa, an advocate for minority rights, and Xheni Karaj, a prominent LGBTI activist, whose perspectives enriched the discussions by bringing the voices of marginalized communities to the forefront. Their inclusion underscored the necessity of addressing the unique challenges faced by these groups in accessing health and education services.

The roundtable brought together public officials, civil society representatives, and advocacy groups, fostering a robust discussion on implementing the report’s recommendations and improving the accountability of public institutions.

This report marks a pivotal step in empowering civil society, promoting evidence-based advocacy, and advancing good governance in Albania.

Full monitoring report in Albanian can be downloaded here.

Full monitoring report in English can be downloaded here.

BIRN Albania Opens Call for Investigative Stories on Healthcare

BIRN Albania launched a call for investigative stories on November 29, offering grants to three journalists to produce articles on the private and public health systems in Albania.

We are offering grants for three talented journalists to delve deep into healthcare-related topics, uncover hidden truths, and shed light on critical issues affecting Albanian citizens.

Why Apply?

  • Financial Support: Receive grants to cover your expenses during your investigations.
  • Mentorship: Work closely with experienced editors who will guide and mentor you, helping you craft compelling stories that adhere to BIRN’s high standards.
  • Impactful Journalism: Contribute to the fight against corruption and impunity, as part of the project “Promoting Accountability and Transparency through Investigative Reporting”, supported by the National Endowment for Democracy (NED).
  • Networking Opportunities: Build connections with journalists, experts, and civil society activists working toward greater transparency and accountability.

Selected journalists will have 3-4 months to investigate their chosen topics, conduct in-depth research, and produce high-quality articles that highlight the challenges and dynamics of Albania’s healthcare systems.

The call only applies to journalists from Albania and closes on December 16, 2024.

Click here for more information (in Albanian) about the application procedure.

Click here to download the application form (in Albanian).

BIRN Albania Holds Roundtable on Healthcare

November 25 roundtable discussed mismanagement and corruption in the health system – and ways to improve service delivery.

The Balkan Investigative Reporting Network in Albania on November 25 held a roundtable in Tirana on the healthcare sector with journalists and experts from civil society organisations.

Two dozen reporters and civil society activists discussed corruption and poor management of the healthcare system in Albania.

The roundtable was moderated by Egla Bardhi, executive director of Together for Life, a civil society watchdog group active in advancing patients rights and monitoring health expenditures.

The roundtable was held as part of the project “Promoting Accountability through Investigative Journalism,” supported by the National Endowment for Democracy (NED).

This project aims to build bridges between journalists and civil society to jointly strengthen the fight against corruption and impunity through investigative journalism.

The topics discussed in the roundtable will inform an upcoming call for investigative grants for mid-career reporters.

The call will fund three reporting grants for journalists that investigate corruption and abuse of office in the helthcare system.

 Topics discussed during the roundtable included:

– Budgeting and insufficient funding for hospitals and services.

– Trade in cytostatic drugs outside the hospital system.

– Lack of enforcement of laws and protocols for treating patients with blood disorders.

– Implementation of hospital autonomy processes and the lack of role of relevant boards.

– Financial interests and political connections behind the list of reimbursable drugs.

– Restrictions and penalties for family doctors by the FSDKSH.

– Evaluation of family doctors’ performance.

– Planning and management of human resources in the healthcare system.

– Shortage of doctors, fictitious payments and benefits, and their costs for the healthcare system.

– Practical implementation of free healthcare for children.

– The issue of children with HIV/AIDS and infections in hospital settings.

– Forensic medicine and reporting of violence against children.

– Misinformation about vaccines and its impact on the population.

BIRN Albania Invites Experts to Develop Internal Procedures for Local Media

The Balkan Investigative Reporting Network in Albania (BIRN Albania) and the Science for Innovation Development Centre (SCiDEV) are seeking a pool of experts to assist in the development of internal procedures for local media organisations.

This call is part of the project “Strengthening Media Freedom, Professionalism, and Journalists’ Safety in Albania”, funded by the European Union and implemented by BIRN Albania in partnership with SCiDEV and Qendra Faktoje.

The project aims to build the capacities of local media and journalists through training and mentoring, enabling them to monitor Albania’s progress on media freedom and address violations of freedom of expression, as well as issues related to journalist safety.

This year, the project has awarded grants to three local media organisations, with plans to support three more next year. An initial assessment of the vulnerabilities and needs of local media organizations has identified the need to develop key internal procedures, which will be supported by this project.

In this context, BIRN Albania and SCiDEV are seeking experts to develop internal procedures for local media organisations in the following areas:

  • Strategic planning development
  • Financial and tendering procedures
  • Administrative procedures
  • Journalist safety and cybersecurity guidelines
  • Social media communication guidelines
  • Editorial guidelines for reporting on sensitive topics and marginalized communities

Experts will be engaged from December 2024 to March 2026 and will provide consultancy within a 10-day timeframe for each procedure.

Experts may apply for more than one procedure and should specify their areas of interest in their letter of interest.

For further information regarding the requirements for this assignment, please click here.

How to Apply: Interested candidates should send the following documents by email to: [email protected]:

  • A Letter of Interest emphasizing previous experience in the area
  • Financial offer (download the form here)
  • CV
  • Contact details of two professional references

Application Deadline: December 2, 2024

Call for Journalists and Researchers on Media Freedom and Journalists’ Safety in Albania

Balkan Investigative Reporting Network in Albania (BIRN Albania) in partnership with the Science for Innovation Development Centre, SCiDEV and Qendra Faktoje is announcing an open call for applications, offering grants to local journalists and researchers to produce research papers and in-depth analyses on media freedom and journalists’ safety in Albania.

BIRN is offering three grants for journalists and researchers to cover their expenses while conducting investigations and research on topics related to media freedom and journalists’ safety in Albania, as well as mentoring by experienced editors.

The call is part of the project “Strengthening Media Freedom, Professionalism and Journalists’ Safety in Albania”, funded by the European Union and implemented by BIRN Albania in partnership with SCiDEV and Qendra Faktoje.

The project aims through training and mentoring to build the capacities of local media and journalists to monitor Albania’s progress on media freedom and flag freedom of expression violations and other issues related to the overall safety of journalists.

The grants to local journalists and researchers to produce research papers or media analyses should prioritize one of the following topics:

  • Impact of media concentration and political interference on editorial independence;
  • Impact of social media and technology on professional journalism;
  • Threats and online harassment of journalists;
  • Protection mechanisms / impunity for attacks on journalists;
  • Challenges in reporting from local and rural areas;
  • Barriers to female journalists’ safety and advancement;
  • Ethical reporting on gender, minorities or marginalized communities;
  • Working conditions and labour rights of journalists and media workers in Albania;
  • Role of disinformation, propaganda or foreign information manipulations and interference (FIMI) in the information ecosystem.

Awarded journalists and researchers will receive a scholarship of 1,500 euros gross (minus personal income tax).

They will have three months to dig deeper and research their ideas. They will also work with experienced editors as mentors to guide them through the process of writing in accordance with BIRN standards.

We encourage the submission of proposals for the production of relevant journalistic content either by individuals or teams. We support various forms, including investigations, data-rich stories and research papers. The call only applies to journalists and researchers from Albania with previous experience on these topics.

All applicants must be independent and free from conflicts of interest in the responsibilities they undertake. Applicants may submit more than one application, but only one proposal per candidate may be awarded.

Interested candidates should send their proposals in Albanian language by email to: [email protected], including: completed application form (click here to download the form); a CV and two examples of their previous work.

Application Deadline: November 20, 2024.

Meet the People Behind BIRN: Vladimir Karaj

Vladimir Karaj has been an editor at BIRN Albania (Reporter.al) since June 2017. Before starting at BIRN, he worked since 2002 for various media outlets as a journalist and editor.

Vladimir also had a stint as the editor-in-chief of a small newspaper. He mainly writes reportages and in-depth stories, predominantly concerning crime and politics. Some stories have marked him, and there are some he sometimes wishes he hadn’t covered because of the scars they left. Despite that, he can’t imagine doing anything else with the same passion and persistence. Recently, he won an EU Award for Investigative Journalism (first prize).

Let’s meet him!

  1. Together with Anesti Barjamemaj, you won the EU Investigative Journalism Awards – first prize for your investigation into environmental crime at the Sharra landfill, exposing toxic waste discharges into the Erzen river. What was working on this investigation like and what were the main obstacles?

How did it all start? Hours of reading official documents, which are typically dull and, more often than not, hold little value for the public. This is a routine part of our work at BIRN. After requesting hundreds of inspection documents from regional offices of the National Environment Agency through FOI requests, we combed through them in search of stories. One of these documents contained details of an inspection conducted at the landfill – a controversial topic in Albania, investigated for years by the Special Prosecution Office. From here, Anesti and I spoke to connected individuals and tried to understand what happened after the inspection and the impact of pollution on the river. The main obstacles in such reporting were the lack of willingness by the authorities to engage or inform the public. For documents that by law should be provided within seven working days, we faced bureaucracy and months of delays.

  1. What does a working day at BIRN Albania look like?

Being part of a small editorial team with colleagues who share the same goals and values is deeply rewarding. We work closely together, fostering a sense of mutual support and shared purpose that is rare in larger newsrooms. The day is filled with discussions, phone calls and hours spent poring over documents and data, all while piecing together stories that might otherwise go unnoticed.

There’s a profound sense of purpose in being part of BIRN in Albania. We know that our work has a tangible impact, both in terms of public awareness and the respect we’ve earned among our readers. The stories we cover are meaningful and frequently provoke public reactions, which reminds us that journalism, even in a small team, can inspire change. It’s this impact, combined with the dedication of the team, that makes the long hours and meticulous work truly fulfilling.

  1. You mainly write reportages and in-depth stories, predominantly concerning crime and politics. Why do you prefer these topics?

It’s not so much a preference as a reality that crime and politics play significant roles in a country like Albania. Both have a deep and pervasive impact on nearly every sector of society, from education and healthcare to environmental issues. Even when you look outside these areas, you often uncover traces of abuse or political negligence because corruption and organised crime are embedded in the very structure of governance and business. This influence seeps into every corner of life, affecting public trust and shaping everyday experiences in ways that are sometimes subtle and other times strikingly overt.

Writing about sports, for example, can easily reveal connections to organised crime and political influence, with cases of match-fixing, money laundering, and favouritism reflecting a broader, ingrained culture of corruption. In countries with high levels of corruption, crime and politics are inescapable – not merely topics of interest but integral forces that shape the economy, social relationships, and the opportunities available to ordinary people. This reality compels journalists like me to focus on these areas, not only to expose the wrongdoings but to help the public understand how deeply rooted these forces are and to bring about some level of accountability.

  1. What would you change if you had a chance to start your career from scratch?

I decided to become a journalist at 17, inspired by a romanticized view of the travel writer, imagining myself uncovering hidden stories. At that age, I saw journalism as a path to adventure, a way to explore unknown places and ideas while sharing them with others. If I were starting over, I’d probably be more rational, choosing this career but with a better understanding of the hard realities it entails – the long hours, the bureaucratic roadblocks, the ethical dilemmas. But even with that more practical view, I don’t think I’d choose a different path.

Over the years, I’ve encountered many stories that, if I had the experience I do now, might have been published and even had an impact. At the beginning of my career, there were investigations that stalled because I wasn’t yet equipped to navigate certain challenges or push back against the roadblocks in my way.

  1. Was there any moment in your career when you thought you should change job to some ‘safer’ profession?

Of course, but not for something safer – I’ve never sought security. There’s a certain drive in journalism that pulls you in, despite the risks and uncertainties. However, there have been moments in my career when I questioned this path, especially after covering events that reveal the darkest sides of humanity. As journalists, we often witness tragedy firsthand and confront raw despair and suffering. These experiences stay with you long after the story is published, leaving an emotional impact that’s hard to shake. There are stories that have marked me, ones I sometimes wish I hadn’t covered because they left scars, moments that haunt you because of the pain and loss they bring into focus.

But despite the moments of doubt, I can’t imagine doing anything else with the same passion and persistence. Journalism has a purpose that’s hard to find elsewhere, and it’s that sense of purpose that keeps me going, even when the job takes an emotional toll.

  1. What would be your message to young aspiring investigative journalists in the Western Balkans region?

It’s hard to encourage someone to choose a job that demands sacrifice and often brings criticism rather than rewards. Journalism can be isolating and challenging, requiring resilience and courage. But the most inspiring message for young journalists comes from seeing impactful work done by those who’ve walked the same path. Knowing others have faced these challenges and still made a difference proves that this work, though difficult, is essential. The reward lies in knowing their efforts contribute to something bigger, inspiring others to keep telling stories that matter.

BIRN Albania Report on anti-NATO and anti-EU Disinformation in Albanian Media Launched

Report blames weak editorial procedures and lack of resources for much of the hostile anti-Western disinformation flowing into the Albanian-language media.

A new study by BIRN Albania that analyzed more than 193,000 articles in 36 Albanian-language news portals reveals how, even in a strongly pro-NATO and pro-EU country, the disinformation narratives of malign foreign actors can penetrate media that have not developed strong editorial procedures and controls.

Research carried by two media experts on behalf of BIRN Albania on disinformation campaigns or narratives by foreign malign forces concluded that such narratives have been present in the Albanian language media environment over the last year, mainly through cracks in editorial procedures amid a myriad of online media outlets, both big and small, although overall the matter is not considered highly problematic.

Distribution of Disinformation Narratives Against NATO and the EU from Adversary Actors in Albanian Media was presented to the public on Friday.

The researchers, Emiljano Kaziaj and Viola Keta, noted that although Albania remains highly pro-NATO and pro-EU, hostile narratives spread by foreign forces can penetrate the media due to several factors, among which the most important seems to be the fragmented nature of the online media landscape,. with many news outlets operating on skeleton editorial staffs eager to get clicks without thinking about what they are publishing.

A copy-pasting culture that emphasizes getting anything possible on the website and with little or no original reporting creates opportunities for the distribution of disinformation narratives that usually aim to justify Russia’s military aggression against Ukraine, portray NATO as a malign force that “provoked” Russia into war, or present the EU as an obsolete and divided structure.

Out of 193,000 news posts identified as related to NATO and the EU published across 36 online media outlets, some 15,177 contained information or points of view from the adversary actors, such as Russia, China or far-right politicians. Researchers interviewed journalists, editors and experts to get an insider view on the matter.

“From the point of view of the journalists and experts interviewed, anti-NATO and anti-EU disinformation does not yet pose a direct threat to the country’s politics or the political and social stability of Albania,” the researchers note.

“This however is a matter that needs to be kept under observation due to the ease with which fake news and or disinformation narratives can spread in an era of online platforms and social media news distribution,” they note.

Disinformation narratives often penetrate the Albanian media from the copy-pasting practice exercised by most online outlets, which, among thousands of news items that they copy from anywhere, also get news that is designed to spread a disinformation narrative.

“Among disinformation narratives, those that portray the European Union and NATO as sinister and expansive organisations with damaging policies against Russia and other countries, and with an agenda for exploitation of people and resources, are the most common,” the researchers note.

“Typically, narratives that target minority groups, such as refugees, LGBTQ or other vulnerable communities, can be detected as originating from the Kremlin, which aims to portray them as a threat to traditional values and as a sign of the degeneration of morals and of perversion,” they add.

The threat of all-out nuclear war between Russia and the West was the most effective disinformation narrative spread in the Albanian media, judged by the number of interactions that this type of news received in social media posts.

The researchers concluded that a lack of financial resources for independent reporting on crises or wars abroad, or on multinational bodies such as NATO and the European Union, are factors that push media to rely on other sources, such as state-owned foreign media that often provide services in Albanian, or use automatic translation to provide free content.

Full report in Albanian can be downloaded here.

Full report in English can be downloaded here.

BIRN Report on Open Data and Digitalization in Western Balkans Presented in Albania

On October 25, BIRN Albania presented the main findings of BIRN’s regional report, “Open Data and Digitalization in the Western Balkans: The State of Play”, to an audience of 25 drawn from the media, research and activist sectors.

The event in Albania was moderated by Kristina Voko, Executive Director of BIRN Albania and a national researcher for the study.

Voko highlighted key findings related to legal assessments, strategies, challenges, and opportunities for open data and digitalization in Albania.

Journalist Vladimir Karaj, who participated in the study, shared his own experiences requesting machine-readable data from public institutions. He discussed the responsiveness of these institutions to providing open, accessible data.

Journalist Ola Xama supported Karaj’s observations, sharing instances where public institutions had either denied data requests or provided data in inaccessible formats, complicating the research process.

Rigels Xhemollari, Executive Director of Civic Resistance, offered insights into public satisfaction in Albania with the e-Albania platform and highlighted the challenges faced by different demographics and local communities.

Megi Reci approached e-government from a human rights perspective, identifying instances of discrimination in data access.

The event concluded with participant discussions, which led to recommendations and ideas for future initiatives. This event is part of the “Open Data and Digitalization in the Western Balkans” project, supported by the Open Society Foundation for the Western Balkans.

The full report is available here.

BIRN Albania Holds Lectures and Rountable on Disinformation

The Balkan Investigative Reporting Network in Albania held three open lectures at Albanian universities and one roundtable on disinformation narratives against NATO and the EU in Albanian media, with more than 110 participants.

The lectures and the rountable presented the findings of the BIRN Albania’s newest study on disinformation narratives against NATO and the EU from hostile states, which was funded by the Open Information Partnership.

The lectures were attended by 88 students, while 30 stakeholders from the fields of journalism, media, research, and civil society participated in the rountable held in Tirana.

 

As part of the study, BIRN Albania monitored more tha 196,000 news articles from 36 Albanian media outlets over a one-year period (May 2023 to May 2024) to identify anti-NATO and anti-EU narratives.

The lectures were held at the European University of Tirana, Beder University and Luigj Gurakuqi University in Shkodra. The rountble was held on October 18 in Tirana.

During the roundtable, Besar Likmeta, Editor-in-Chief of BIRN Albania, shared the findings on the main narratives against NATO and the EU that were most often repeated in the monitored media.

He emphasized that these narratives include claims that NATO is an expansionist organisation pursuing an agenda to destabilize the Balkans, that the EU is divided and unable to protect its citizens, and that the West supports elites at the expense of the people. Likmeta also presented several common features that help distinguish disinformation articles from credible reporting.

Meanwhile, Viola Keta, a journalist and co-author of the study, discussed some of the challenges in reporting news related to NATO, the EU, and related topics, along with recommendations identified during interviews with media managers, editors, journalists, and social media managers from some news media in Albania.

At the end of the events, participants expressed their concerns about disinformation narratives and discussed possible future steps to counter them.

Journalists Who Investigated Toxic Waste Win Press Awards in Albania

Six journalists were handed awards at the EU Investigative Journalism Awards on Thursday for outstanding stories published in Albania last year.

Stories about toxic waste, a controversial incinerator project, and challenges faced by the Balkan farmers were among the winning reports.

Anesti Barjamemaj, Vladimir Karaj, Oli Xama, Geri Emiri, Aida Ciro and Aleksandar Dimitrievski were announced as winners at the annual awards held at Europe House in Tirana.

The first prize went to Anesti Barjamemaj and Vladimir Karaj from Reporter.al and Voice of America for their investigation into environmental crime at the Sharra landfill, exposing toxic waste discharges into the Erzen river.

The second prize was handed to Ola Xama, also from Reporter.al, for a story that uncovered the role of the mayor of Tirana in the controversial Tirana incinerator project.

The third place went to Geri Emiri, Aida Ciro, and Aleksandar Dimitrievski from Amfora.al for their work highlighting the challenges faced by Balkan farmers in accessing EU funds.

The jury consisted of Ilda Londo from the Albanian Media Institute, Albana Kasapi, a senior journalist and editor at the BBC’s World Service Radio and Elira Canga, a media development expert.