Life in Viti

Appearing on “Life in the Municipality,” opposition and civil society members accused Viti Mayor Nexhmedin Arifi, a member of the PDK, of blocking economic development and favoring party supporters and family members during his mandate.

Monitors from BIRN and the GAP Institute have found that some tenders have indeed been won by party supporters and family members. Among others, a contract for supplying water and food to kindergartens and the tender for an ambulance, valued at 35,000 euros, were won by the company Shpetimi, whose owners include municipal advisor Besim Halimi, a member of the PDK.

Automobile insurance is provided by Siguria, which is owned by the deputy head of the municipality. According to Mayor Arifi, the company was chosen because it “offered the lowest prices in the tender.” Meanwhile, the company that supplies fuel for municipal cars, IziPetro, has a representative who is the brother of the municipal director of agriculture.  Arifi said that the contract was signed before the director got his job. “He does not hold this contract anymore.”

During the debate, Arifi boasted that he had built a cemetery for veterans just outside of the municipality of Viti and had overseen construction of the city’s square, parking spaces and road signals. He also touted the completion of a municipal legal structure.

“Together with the opposition we managed to create the commission on a municipal level and by complying with all procedures, the status of the municipality was approved,” he said.

But Hasan Alia from the opposition party LDK said the legal initiative came from his party. Alia also criticised the mayor’s administration. “The administration cannot be considered efficient when it has four or five directors on its board who are working for the first time; it is not an efficient administration when the mayor continually pursues his own interest,” he said.

Vetevendosje members criticized all the parties that are part of the municipal assembly for violating legal provisions. Arton Muslia said that the opposition cannot be freed from responsibility since it has been part of the decisions.

“For two years in a row the (municipal) status hasn’t been approved and the mayor is not the only one responsible for this,” said Muslia, adding: “the opposition does not exist in Viti”.

He proceeded with accusations of budget mismanagement, mentioning that 208,000 euros were expended for maintaining roads; 10,000 euros for paint; 60,000 for the tender to build the dam for irrigation, and others. Apart from expenditures, according to him, the results of these projects are nowhere to be seen.

“The political scene of Viti is depoliticized. In general, politics here is reduced to salaries, per diems, and services, whereas the residents are not able to enjoy the goods that they should have,” Muslia said.

Of the electoral promises of 2009, few have been implemented in practice. Among others, the construction of the bridge at Viti’s outskirts started two years ago, but it hasn’t been completed. The municipality says that works have been suspended because of the objections of one resident.

In addition, the lack of a municipal building has caused the municipal administration to continue to work in seven different facilities.

Life in Suhareka

During the 2009 electoral campaign, Blerim Kuci, who was running for mayor of Suhareka, promised enough water for the residents of Suhareka, support for farmers, repairs to the bridge over the River Theranda and construction of a cultural center. “Life in the Municipality” looked at the ways Kuci has lived up to his promises, and the ways he hasn’t.

 

Two and a half years after his election, one of the main electoral promises, the steady supply of drinking water, seems to be making good progress. Suhareka now has 200 liters more water per second.  With the help of international donors, wells have been dug, and work is being done to extend the water supply system to villages.

Kuci, who is from the AAK, said that the city, which had been ruled by LDK since the war, now has water 24 hours a day. “Before my mandate there was never water … we have paid special attention to water,” he said.

Opposition parties, meanwhile, say that the problem hasn’t been solved but there has been some progress with the help of USAID.

Florim Kryeziu from PDK said that in some villages of Suhareka, the lack of drinking water continues to be a problem.
“Another five million euros are needed to supply all the villages of Theranda with water,” Kuci said. He would not promise that during his mandate all villages would have drinking water.

During the electoral campaign Kuci also promised to provide subsidies for farmers. Speaking on “Life in the Municipality”, he said that 2 million euros have been distributed, but the opposition says that subsidies have gone mainly to Kuci’s political party supporters.

Kuci said that a municipal agency has now been established that is tasked with supporting the farmers by drafting projects and raising funds to develop agriculture. Through this agency, according to Kuci, 2 million euros in subsidies have been given to farmers.

However, Shefket Kolgeci from the LDK said that subsidies for farmers haven’t reached the “right addresses”.
“Farmers subsidies have gone to those who favor members of his party, and those who gave their ballots during the campaign,” Kolgeci said.

The opposition also accused the mayor of mismanaging the budget.  Kolgeci said that the peak of mismanagement was the construction of the bridge over river Theranda.

“This project started in August of 2011, while the money was given in 2010. But work still hasn’t started,” he said.

The team of observers from BIRN and GAP have found that the electoral promises kept include the construction of protective barriers on the road from Qafa e Duhles to Suhareka; the elimination of a requirement that parents must pay their property tax before receiving a birth certificate for their newborn child, and Mayor Kuci’s meetings with residents, which occur every Tuesday. But Kuci’s promise to cut unemployment has not been realized.

The residents of the municipality of Theranda that participated in the debate asked Kuci about a range of issues- from unemployment to the general infrastructure of the municipality.

Life in Drenas

Two-and-a-half years since promises were made in Drenas, opposition politicians and civil society said on the show “Life in Kosovo” that only 50 percent of the promised projects have been implemented — and those that have are of low quality.

Rifat Bilalli of the Democratic League of Dardania said during a debate broadcast on Radio Television of Kosovo that “the roads, pipe systems, and water supply systems that have been built are of extremely low quality.”

“The pipes have only been ‘buried,’ while they barely function,” Bilall said.

According to the opposition, the most grandiose promise made by Drenas Mayor Nexhat Demaku- to build an industrial center- has remained simply a pre-election promise.

“The Industrial Business Center in front of the Business Park has not yet been started… the deadlines which mayor Demaku talked about have failed; they passed long ago,” said Petrit Bajraktari from Vetevendosje.

Bekim Dobra, a Koha Ditore journalist who is from Drenas, said that this major project hasn’t started yet, even though the mayor promised that it would be built within the two years following the election.

Mayor Demaku, meanwhile, said the municipality has done a lot to repair infrastructure, such as roads, sewage systems and water supply systems.

During the show, Demaku was praised for building the central square in Drenas, the Ali Bajraktari school and public housing.
The team of observers from BIRN and the GAP Institute also found that Demaku fulfilled some campaign promises, including the construction of the Fehmi Lladrovci high school, the renovation of the local emergency room and the establishment of subsidies for farmers.

But others haven’t been fulfilled, including repairing the Drenas riverbed, improving the safety conditions at the aging Arllati school, and minimal repair done to the roads of the Shtutice and Cikatove villages.

Another problem that was raised during the debate was the transportation of students in vans to schools in the Arllat and Llapushnik villages. The transport was arranged by the municipality, however a commission has determined that student safety is threatened because the vans are overloaded with students, and have at times been driven by individuals under the age of 18.

Mayor Demaku was not able to justify the decision to again award the tender to a company owned by the brothers Thaci and managed by the municipal advisor, Elmi Thaci, despite the complaints.

Another promise of Mayor Demaku during the 2009 campaign was the repair of the sewage treatment plant. The opposition and civil society groups said the project hasn’t been fully implemented, despite some progress.

Demaku said work has started on the plant in Korretice, in collaboration with the Ministry of Commerce. “But it hasn’t been fully implemented because of opposition by some residents,” he explained.

Drenas residents that participated in the debate asked the mayor about issues including road infrastructure, sewage systems and the water supply system in their villages. Demaku said the budget of the municipality is around 9.4 million euros, which is smaller than some other municipalities with less territory and fewer residents.

Life in the Municipality

Two years after the November 2009 Local Elections, Balkan Investigative Reporting Network – BIRN in close cooperation with the Institute for Advanced Studies – GAP and Advocacy, Training, and Resource Centre – ATRC returned to every Kosovo municipality with the intention of organising post-election debates with all 34 elected mayors.

The final aim was to check and evaluate to what extent the public pledges made during the election campaign were fulfilled and analyse the quality of delivery.

BIRN Offices Hold Joint Meeting On Regional Investigations

BIRN HUB and BIRN Bosnia and Herzegovina held a joint meeting in Sarajevo on Wednesday to discuss a series of upcoming regional investigations.  

The two offices of the Balkan Investigative Reporting Network discussed topics for regional investigations related to transitional justice.

“Our future investigations need to tackle issues of transitional justice that will prompt debate in our societies,” said Gordana Igric, regional director of BIRN.

Igric added that a regional approach to these issues is crucial, as almost every story related to the conflict in the 1990s affects at least two countries in the former Yugoslavia.

The meeting was attended by: Marija Ristic, BTJ Serbian correspondent, Elvira Jukic, journalist, Erna Mackic, Editor in Chief BIRN BiH, Marija Tausan, BIRN Justice Report journalist and Editor, Albina Sorguc, Journalist, Amer Jahic, Journalist, Mirna Buljugic, BIRN Justice Report journalist, Dragana Erjavec, TV Justice journalist and Editor, Selma Ucanbarlic, Journalist/Court reporter, Melisa Bilalovic, Radio Justice Editor and Boris Pavelic, Balkan Transitional Justice Croatia Correspondent.

The investigations are part of BIRN’s Regional Reporting on Transitional Justice Issues programme. Over the next two years, the organisation’s network of journalists will produce four investigations on transitional justice issues in the region.

The topics for investigations will be finalised in January in Belgrade at a joint editorial meeting.

BIRN teaches voters how to fight electoral violations

High school students competed with one another to see who could identify more electoral procedure violations during imaginary cases presented by a BIRN team of lawyers and experts. 

It was one part of 10 BIRN presentations on electoral procedures in the municipalities of Obiliq, Mitrovica, Drenas, Fushe Kosove, Suhareka, Kamenica, Prizren, Ferizaj, Hani i Elezit and in Gjilan that were held during October and November 2012.

These presentations gathered 200 first-time voters. They were trained on the electoral process focusing on election frauds, complaint procedures, available penalties, and competent institutions to deal with complaints.

The presentations focused on electoral complaint procedures and institutions. First, the BIRN team offered a comprehensive presentation on these procedures, followed with concrete examples of how BIRN has monitored elections.

The presentations lasted about an hour and were followed with an exercise, in which high school students were presented with an imaginary case.

The BIRN team worked closely with students in order to explain to them how to fill the complaint, what evidence is acceptable for ECAP, how to present evidence in ECAP and other legal elements of the complaints.

After students competed in finding electorial violations, trainers engaged them in discussion.

Questions included: How a witness of a violation during the election should report the case to the relevant institutions? How should a person react, in cases when he or she has been present at the time and place where the violation has occurred? Will there be ask risk to them for reporting the violations?

BIRN Reporters Awarded for Anti-Corruption Journalism

BIRN journalists Parim Olluri, Kreshnik Gashi and Alban Selimi have been awarded in Kosovo for their anti-corruption journalism.

The United Nations Development Program, in collaboration with Kosovo’s Anti-Corruption Agency and the Association of Professional Journalists in Kosovo, awarded the prizes for the seventh year.

Parim Olluri, a journalist for BIRN’s Gazeta Jeta ne Kosovo, received the award for the best article on issues of corruption in online media.

He was recognized for a series of articles about Kosovo’s prime minister and several well-known businessmen who are close to him.

The jury said Olluri was honoured for the quality of his articles, the impact they had, and his persistence in following up on the stories.  

Kreshnik Gashi and Alban Selimi received the award for best anti-corruption TV investigation. The two BIRN journalists produced a story on bribery within the ranks of the police, which was part of BIRN’s “Justice in Kosovo” program.

The jury commended Gashi and Selimi for the content of their story as well as the manner in which they carried out their investigation

The award for print media went to journalists Vehbi Kajtazi and Besnik Krasniqi from Koha Ditore daily. Jeton Llapashtica of Zeri newspaper was also recognized.

Imer Mushkolaj, executive director of the Association of Professional Journalists of Kosovo, told the journalists that their work is crucial to Kosovo’s development.

“The media cannot win the war against corruption, yet without the media, the war against corruption is impossible,” he told those gathered.

BIRN Investigative Journalists meet in Belgrade

BIRN investigative reporters met for the first time this year to discuss story ideas and possible regional cooperation in the Serbian capital on October 29, 2012.

Balkan Insight’s Besar Likmeta of Albania, Elvira Jukic of Bosnia and Bojana Barlovac of Serbia, along with Belgrade Insight’s Gordana Andric, BIRN Serbia’s Aleksandar Djordjevic, and Semir Mujkic, an investigative journalist for the Bosnian Zurnal magazine, gathered in Belgrade and brainstormed ideas for regional cooperation on investigative pieces.

BIRN Regional Director Gordana Igric and Balkan Insight Managing Editor Ana Petruseva guided the journalists through different topic possibilities.

Investigations are an important part of BIRN’s publishing activities and the BIRN team is always preparing new stories.

Over the next year, BIRN journalists will work on several regional investigative projects that are relevant to the Balkans and beyond.

BIRN Bosnia Holds Training for Journalists

The Balkan Investigative Reporting Network of Bosnia and Herzegovina, supported by the OSCE, is organizing a five-day training for journalists from various parts of the country, aimed to improve court reporting on war crimes trials.

The training takes place in Sarajevo from December 10 to 14 and journalists will have an opportunity to listen about the work of judicial institutions from judges and prosecutors, legal experts and other assistants directly involved in war crime trials.

Ten journalists from Doboj, Livno, Mostar, Travnik, Bijeljina, Sarajevo, Brčko, Trebinje, Tuzla and Gorazda will attend the training. The journalists will attend war crime trials and report about what they witnessed in court. They will also have the opportunity to work closely with BIRN editors and journalists, in order to learn about the court reporting process, how to avoid mistakes and how to recognise ethical and professional traps in their work.

In addition, the journalists will get to learn about the importance of reporting on facts and the dangers of irresponsible reporting, which can lead to lawsuits and contempt of court charges.

BIRN and OSCE recognised the need to organise such a training as many war crimes cases have been transferred to the Cantonal, District and Brcko district Court from the Bosnian State Court. The goal of the training is to improve reporting on war crime trials at the local courts.

The aim of the raining is to develop journalists’ court reporting skills in line with International and domestic standards and become certified court reporters in their media.

BIRN Bosnia and Herzegovina is one of the key actors in brining justice processes to citizens of the country and the region since 2004. In the past seven years, BIRN BiH has informed the public daily about war crimes prosecutions and transitional justice issues which affect their lives.

Media on Mladic: Parallel Universes

Balkan Investigating Reporting Network (BIRN) has presented on Tuesday its publication “Spotlight on Mladic: Villian or Celebrity?”, which analyses how the media in the region reported on the arrest and trial of Ratko Mladic, the former Bosnian Serb army commander.

The book, published with the support from the Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, concluded that the media in the former Yugoslav countries presented these events from different angles.

It was pointed out at the promotion that media reports from Bosnia and Herzegovina reflected the entity division of the country, while in Serbia, Mladic, charged with genocide and other crimes in Bosnia and Herzegovina, was painted as a celebrity.

The media in Croatia focused on the disappointment that the Hague Tribunal did not charge Mladic with crimes committed in that country.

“It is sad we don’t share the same views and I think we are trapped in parallel universes which are completely different,” said Gordana Igric, the publication’s editor.

Marija Ristic, the journalist who analysed the media reports in Serbia, described them as trivial and that more attention was dedicated to what Mladic was doing at the time of his arrest or the treatment he had in the Hague Tribunal than the crimes he is accused of.

“That kind of reporting is actually the testament to the unwillingness of Serbia and its citizens to face their past,” said Ristic.  

Erna Mackic, who analysed the texts in Bosnia and Herzegovina, said that the journalist reports in the entity media reflected comments made by politicians during the arrest and Mladic’s trial.

“In the Federation, people were delighted, while in Republika Srpska it was said that the court should be left alone to establish whether Mladic was guilty of committing crimes in Bosnia and Herzegovina or not, also neglecting statements from victims,” said Mackic.

Speaking at the presentation of the book, Boris Pavelic, journalist from Croatia, said that the Hague Tribunal was condemned as the worst court possible up until November 16, 2012, when it acquitted the Croatian generals, Ante Gotovina and Mladen Markac,  becoming the best court ever.

Christian Axboe Nielsen, a historian, talked about the issues that media failed to deal with, as well as the Hague Tribunal itself, emphasising that the court’s achievements would not matter historically if the national courts did not resume its work.

According to Nerma Jelacic, the spokesperson of the Hague Tribunal, the results of the work and efficiency of this court would be best perceived from the distance of around ten years.