Reporting Corruption on Broadcast and Print Media: The Case of Albania

The media monitoring study assesses Albanian media reporting on corruption, as well as its adherence to the guiding principles of journalism which make it possible for news organizations to be an effective tool against corruption.

The objective of the study is to present and interpret a summary of the general characteristics as well as the quality and reliability of the reporting of Albanian media on issues and cases of corruption, based on a set of quantitative indicators, in order to identify possible problems and shortfalls in the implementation of journalistic standards.

The findings of this monitoring initiative are intended to be used as reference material to assist the various local and international actors involved in media development in Albania, local journalists’ unions, as well as reporters and editors, in undertaking projects and activities that could eventually increase both the quantity and the quality of reporting on corruption, impunity and efficiency of anti-corruption initiatives.

To download a copy of the report in Albanian click here.

To download a copy of the report in English click here.

Thirrje për Shprehje Interesi

Forcimi i Transparencës në Procedurat e Prokurimit Publik përmes Gazetarisë Investigative

Tiranë, Maj 8-9, 2015

Rrjeti Ballkanik për Gazetarinë Investigative në Shqipëri (BIRN Albania), në kuadër të projektit ‘Forcimi i Transparencës në Procedurat e Prokurimit Publik përmes Gazetarisë Investigative’ të mbështetur nga USAID përmes Assist Impact, do të organizojë një trajnim dy-ditor mbi teknikat e gazetarisë investigative në fushën e prokurimeve publike.
Përmes kësaj thirrjeje për shprehje interesi, BIRN Albania kërkon të angazhojë 12-15 gazetarë nga të gjitha rajonet e vendit që të marrin pjesë në këtë trajnimin mbi gazetarinë investigative që do të zhvillohet më datat 8-9 Maj 2015 në Tiranë.

Prezantimi i trajnimit:

Ky trajnim dy-ditor ka për qëllim të ofrojë një guidë të metodave dhe teknikave bazë të gazetarisë investigative, si dhe njohuri më të thelluara mbi procedurat e prokurimit publik në Shqipëri. Ai synon të ngrejë njohuritë dhe aftësitë e gazetarëve për të ndjekur në mënyrë më sistemike çështjet e konfliktit të interesit, për të zbuluar fakte dhe për të prodhuar gazetari cilësore bazuar në mbledhjen dhe analizimin e fakteve dhe publikimin e dokumenteve.

Kujt i drejtohet ky trajnim:

Trajnimi i drejtohet gazetarëve shqiptarë të cilët janë të interesuar për të thelluar njohuritë e tyre mbi teknikat e gazetarisë investigative dhe procedurat e prokurimit publik. Gazetarët që punojnë në zonat jashtë Tiranës janë të inkurajuar të aplikojnë. BIRN Albania do të mbulojë kostot e udhëtimit për të gjithë pjesëmarrësit nga rrethet.

Objektivat e trajnimit:

Objektivat e trajnimit janë që pjesëmarrësit:

  1. Të thellojnë njohuritë e tyre mbi konceptet dhe parimet e gazetarisë investigative;
  2. Të përmirësojnë aplikimin e teknikave dhe metodave të gazetarisë investigative;
  3. Të thellojnë njohuritë mbi procedurat e prokurimit publik në Shqipëri.

Përmbajtja e trajnimit:

Komponentët bazë të trajnimit mbi raportimin investigativ do të jenë:

  • Artikuj investigativë bazuar në të dhëna;
  • Investigimi i individëve dhe kompanive/institucioneve;
  • Vënia në zbatim e Ligjit për të Drejtën e Informimit;
  • Teknikat e intervistimit;
  • Thellimi i njohurive mbi procedurat e prokurimit publik në Shqipëri.

Procedura e aplikimit:

Kandidatët e interesuar duhet të dërgojnë një CV dhe një letër shprehje interesi në adresën e e-mailit [email protected]. Aplikimet për këtë trajnim përfundojnë të martën, datë 5 Maj. Kandidatët e përzgjedhur do të njoftohen menjëherë pas kësaj date.

Mbështetje e pjesëmarrësve:

Gazetarët pjesëmarrës në këtë trajnim do të marrin pjesë në një konkurs, me anë të të cilit BIRN Albania përmes një jurie të pavarur do të përzgjedhë 6 propozime për investigime në fushën e prokurimeve publike. Këto investigime do të mbështeten financiarisht nga BIRN Albania dhe përmes mbështetjes teknike të stafit të saj do të botohen në dy mediat online: BalkanInsight.com dhe Reporter.al.

Call for Expression of Interest

Fostering Transparency in Procurement Procedures Through Investigative Journalism

Tirana, May 8-9, 2015

Introduction:

The 2-day training serves to provide a guide of basic methods and techniques of investigative journalism as well as an overview of the public procurement procedures in Albania. It aims to strengthen the skills and training of mid-level journalists to look closely at systemic issues of conflict of interest, uncover facts and produce compelling journalism by performing data gathering and analysis, document mining.

Who should attend?

The training targets mid-career journalists in Albania.

Workshop objective:

The outcome for participants will be:

  1. Improved understanding of the concept and principles of investigative journalism;
  2. Improved applied methods and techniques of investigative journalism
  3. Improved understanding of Albania’s public procurement process

 Workshop content

Key content for the Investigative Reporting workshop will include: 

  • Data-Driven Investigative Stories;
  • Computer-Assisted Reporting;
  • Investigating Individuals, and organizations;
  • Navigating Albania’s FOI Law
  • The art of interviewing.
  • Understanding the public procurement procedures in Albania

Selection Process

BIRN Albania is seeking 15 successful candidates to attend the investigative journalism training workshop on May 8th-9th 2015.

Bursaries:

The journalist part of the training will participate in a competition, from which BIRN Albania through and independent jury will select six story ideas for investigations on public procurement that will be funded and published with the help of BIRN Editors in its online publications BalkanInsight.com and Reporter.al. BIRN Albania will cover travel costs for journalists outside Tirana.

Applications

Applications for this training close on Tuesday, May 5th. Interested candidates must sent a CV and motivation letter to [email protected] . Successful candidates will be informed shortly thereafter.

Deniz Sllovinja

Deniz is a cameraman and video editor for Kallxo.com and the BIRN TV programmes Life in Kosovo and Justice in Kosovo.

Deniz has been working in media production since his youth. Before joining BIRN in 2013, Deniz worked for Foto Canon and Top Kosova TV as a video editor.

Deniz is currently studying communications and production at AAB-RIINVEST University.

Behar Mustafa

Behar Mustafa is a court monitor and researcher working in the Mitrovica region and contributes as a journalist to the TV programme Justice in Kosovo.

Before joining BIRN in 2014, he worked in various NGOs and media outlets, including the daily newspaper Koha Ditore, where he served as Vushtrri correspondent, and Kosova Channel in Mitrovica.

Behar has a BA degree in law and is currently pursuing his Master’s degree.

BIRN Albania launches Media Monitoring Study on Corruption

The Balkan Investigative Reporting Network in Albania launched a media monitoring study, ‘Reporting Corruption on Broadcast and Print Media: The Case of Albania’, at a workshop in Tirana on Thursday April 16.

About 25 representatives of civil society organizations and journalists participated in the event at which the findings of the study were presented and debated.

The study is part of BIRN Albania’s programme called ‘Exposing Corruption in Albania’, which is financed by the Open Society Foundation in Albania (OSFA).

The report assessed Albanian media reporting on corruption, as well as its adherence to the guiding principles of journalism which make it possible for news organizations to be an effective tool against corruption.

The objective of the study is to present and interpret a summary of the general characteristics as well as the quality and reliability of the reporting of Albanian media on issues and cases of corruption, based on a set of quantitative indicators, in order to identify possible problems and shortfalls in the implementation of journalistic standards.

The findings of this monitoring initiative are intended to be used as reference material to assist the various local and international actors involved in media development in Albania, local journalists’ unions, as well as reporters and editors, in undertaking projects and activities that could eventually increase both the quantity and the quality of reporting on corruption, impunity and efficiency of anti-corruption initiatives.

To download a copy of the report in Albanian click here.

To download a copy of the report in English click here.

Durim Shala

Durim Shala is an Assistant Producer / Cameraman and Editor for Life in Kosovo and Justice in Kosovo.

Durim’s main responsibilities are recording and editing videos for Life in Kosovo and Justice in Kosovo TV programmes. Additionally,
Durim records Kosovo Police operations that are shown on the “Police” segment of Justice in Kosovo.

Durim joined BIRN in 2013. He is pursuing his BA degree in Marketing from University of Prishtina.

 

Rrahman Ramaj

Rrahman Ramaj is a financial analyst for BIRN Kosovo.

He monitors public spending by analysing procurement contracts and audit reports of municipalities across Kosovo , and monitoring of procurement offices.

Rrahman, who joined BIRN in 2014, is the co-author of a report on public procurement, titled, ,Hidden Tenders”, published in February 2015.

Rrahman holds a BA in Finance and Accounting from the University of Prishtina, where he is currently pursuing his master’s degree in Management and IT.

Fellows for 2015 Selected

The 10 participants for this year’s Balkan Fellowship for Journalistic Excellence have been chosen.

The programme received more than 150 applications and many were of a very high standard, making the final choice extremely difficult.

Members of the programme’s independent selection committee evaluate applications based on the relevance, feasibility and originality of the proposals, as well as the applicants’ professional qualifications, motivation and journalistic approach. The committee is comprised of seven senior media figures from the Balkans and around Europe.

BIRN and its partners in the fellowship programme thank all the applicants and encourage those who were not successful to consider applying again next year.

Here are the fellows for 2015, listed alphabetically by surname:

Fotini Barka (Greece)

Lindita Cela (Albania)

Vladimir Karaj (Albania)

Konstantinos Koukoumakas (Greece)

Jasmina Lazic (Serbia)

Jeton Mehmeti (Kosovo)

Mariya Petkova (Bulgaria)

Damir Pilic (Croatia)

Laura Stefanut (Romania)

Zornitsa Stoilova (Bulgaria)

The Fellows’ topics will be published in due course. They include the effects of the war in Syria, religious tension, human trafficking, education, culture and labour conditions.

The word cloud above gives a flavour of the topics covered in previous years, drawing on the headlines and introductions of Fellowship stories.

BIRN Serbia Holds Heathcare Financing Debate

The debate on Tuesday heard how the Law on Public Procurement is causing problems for the healthcare system and needs to be changed.

Berislav Vekić, state secretary at the Ministry of Health, told the reminded that the ministry had launched an initiative to change the law.

“We cannot, as a ministry, change the law by ourselves, it is up to the government,” he said, adding that although he expects changes, he cannot promise anything.

Vekić noted that health minister Zlatibor Loncar has already taken the initiative and raised the public procurement problem in the Serbian assembly.

He said that there were problem not only with acquiring linear accelerators, but also magnets, scanners, large appliances for diagnostic procedures, ultrasound and X-ray machines.

“We are the first ministry that acknowledged the data that we have 65 per cent of total health personnel – doctors – who are aged between 55 and 65 years. I wonder what has been done in previous years regarding the rejuvenation of staff and why nobody made sure that we didn’t get into a situation of shortage of specialist personnel in certain areas,” Vekić said.

He said that nearly a third of staff employed in health institutions are actually non-medical staff. “The previous administration employed drivers, porters, stokers and administrative staff, so every third person is a non-medical worker,” said Vekić.

He added that last year about 1,000 health workers were employed – 400 doctors and 600 nurses and medical technicians.

Opposition Democratic Party MP and member of the parliamentary committee for Health and Family, Dušan Milisavljević said that politics should not be the deciding factor in the health sector, noting that many previous governments, including his own, hadn’t considered health and the health sector a priority.

“The health sector is outdated and does not reflect the needs of the citizens of Serbia at the present time,” he said, naming the Law on Public Procurement as one of the major problems.

“Because of this law we are waiting for a radiation therapy appliance for 2.5 years, so patients suffering from severe malignant diseases are waiting in line for radiation therapy for several months, although it has to be done after two, not more than three weeks after surgery,” Milisavljevic explained.  

He said that the law is generally not bad since it centralizes the procurement process and thus decreases the possibility for corruption, but it needs to be changed and adjusted to actual needs.  

Director of legal affairs of the Republic Fund for Health Insurance (RFZO) Petar Stajković said that it was impossible for two or three regulations to solve all problems.

Stajković said there are two crucial laws that even do not recognize the system of health insurance and health care – the Public Procurements Law and the Law on the Budget System.   

“The Law on public procurement of medical equipment and medicines is implemented in the same way one procures chemicals for household maintenance,” warned Stajkovic.

He said that the Law on the Budget System does not recognize health issues in a proper way, as health institutions aren’t budgetary institutions but direct users of public funds through contracts, and rigid application of the law very often leads healthcare institutions into problems.

At the debate, participants also got acquainted with the results of the analysis of the sources of finance for healthcare institutions, implemented by CSO Legal Scanner, and its main finding that some regulations govern the area of finance in a direct way, while others require specific legal interpretation and so have to be changed and unified with other legislative documents in this area.

This debate and the report on sources of financing of health care institutions were produced with the financial assistance of the European Union, within the programme “Strengthening Media Freedom”. The views expressed at the debate and the contents of the document are the sole responsibility of BIRN Serbia and other event participants and can under no circumstances be regarded as reflecting the position of the European Union.