BIRN Journalists Win Serbian Investigative Reporting Award

The Independent Association of Journalists of Serbia and the US Embassy in Belgrade have awarded BIRN journalists Slobodan Georgiev and Aleksandar Djordjevic the 2014 prize for investigative journalism in the print media category.

Georgiev and Djordjevic won the award for their report entitled ‘Marketing Stars in the Political Field’, which was published in the weekly magazine Vreme in March 2014. The investigation showed how Serbian Prime Minister Aleksandar Vucic’s party entered the advertising market after coming to power in 2012, pushing out the Democrats who previously held a dominant influence in this sector.

The journalists were presented with the awards, which carry a $1,200 prize, by US ambassador Michael Kirby at a ceremony on Thursday.

Kirby said that he respects the work of the Serbian prime minister and changes to the Serbian media laws, but also said that “these laws do not cover the biggest challenge for the media, and that’s lack of money. Media need money to survive, provide salaries to journalists, but also to pay other bills.”

Separate prizes were also awarded in two other categories, electronic and online media.

The electronic media (radio and television) award went to Vesna Radojevic and Andjela Milivojevic from TV Mreza and the Centre for Investigative Reporting in Serbia (CINS) for their story about a housing swindle.

The online media award was given to Dragana Peco, Dino Jahic and Jasna Fetahovic from CINS for an article about corrupt practices in the awarding of prizes to Serbian business leaders, which was published on the website of CINS and CIN Sarajevo in August 2013. Jahic is an alumnus of BIRN’s Balkan Fellowship for Journalistic Excellence.

Another BIRN Serbia journalist Ana Novakovic, was nominated in the online media category together with Georgiev, for their story ‘TV Viewers Force Fed State Spin’ about the Serbian state hiring three private companies to produce material that TV stations use for free without informing viewers that it is not news, but PR.

The winners were chosen by a jury composed of journalist and media consultant Sasa Lekovic, director of the Center for Investigative Reporting Branko Cecen, ‘Insajder’ TV show journalist Ivan Angelovski, and investigative journalist and editor of Novi Magazin Milorad Ivanovic.

BIRN Serbia Journalists Shortlisted for Investigative Award

BIRN Serbia journalists Ana Novakovic, Slobodan Georgiev and Aleksandar Djordjevic have been named as finalists for the National Investigative Journalism Award 2014 by the Independent Association of Journalists in Serbia.

Novakovic and Georgiev were selected in the online media category for their article for Balkan Insight about the Serbian state hiring three private companies to produce material that TV stations use for free without informing viewers that it is not news, but PR.

The investigation showed that the state spent at least €3.8 million over the past nine years, despite already financing two costly public media outlets. The story can be found at http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/tv-viewers-force-fed-state-spin

Georgiev was also nominated together with Djordjevic in the print media category for their investigation that showed how Serbian Prime Minister Aleksandar Vucic’s party entered the advertising market after coming to power in 2012, pushing out the Democrats who previously held a dominant influence in this sector.

The article was published in weekly news magazine Vreme, but can also be found online at http://javno.rs/istrazivanja/oglasavanje-kao-privatni-posao-vlasti/

Others nominated in the online media category are three journalists from the Centre for Investigative Journalism in Serbia, Dragana Peco, Jasna Fetahovic and Dino Jahic, who is also a Balkan Fellowship for Journalistic Excellence alumnus.

In the print media category, the other selected journalists are Nikola Lazic from the weekly Vranjske and Jelena Veljkovic, a freelancer.

The Investigative Journalism Award is organised by the Independent Association of Journalists in Serbia and is supported by the US Embassy in Belgrade. The winners will be announced at an awards ceremony in Belgrade on May 8.

 

Research on Soft Censorship in Serbia Published

‘Soft Censorship: Strangling Serbia’s Media’, a piece of research conducted by the World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers (WAN-IFRA) and the Balkan Investigative Reporting Network (BIRN), in cooperation with the Center for International Media Assistance – CIMA, is published today and will be presented at the ‘Media Freedom and Accession talks – Speak Up! Serbia’ conference in Brussels.

The report describes the mechanisms of a growing ‘soft censorship’ that denies Serbia’s citizens their right to a free and independent media and offers recommendations that can help tackle such practices.

The EP’s rapporteur on Serbia, Jelko Kacin, one of the conference organizers, said that adoption of media laws is one of the main tasks of the new government. 

According to Kacin, the three biggest problems of the Serbian media sector are self-censorship and a lack of investigative journalism, non-transparency of ownership, and the rise of tabloids. 

BIRN’s regional director, Gordana Igrić, presenting an overview of the research in Brussels, said that the system of censorship in Serbia has been established earlier, during the Democratic Party’s time in office.

Serbia’s chief negotiator with the European Union, Tanja Miščević, emphasized that the government will submit media bills to the parliament as soon as possible, but pointed out that it is more important for such laws to be implemented in practice. 

The main researcher on the project was Jovanka Matić, and it was supported by Open Society Foundations.

BIRN Serbia Website Launches 2014 Elections Page

Helping Serbian voters to make an informed electoral decision, BIRN Serbia redesign its MeraVlade website introducing new page dedicated to the 2014 parliamentary elections, featuring seven political parties’ promises related to the primary topics of citizens’ concern: economy, the fight against corruption, health and education. 

The new web page serves as an easy-to-use online tool which provides information about the parties, their statements and promises made to the electorate, as well as up-to-date news from the campaign.

BIRN’s monitoring of the Serbian election campaign shows that most common promises from the parties are about economic development (particularly unemployment and new jobs) and the consolidation of public finances. Almost 60 per cent of all promises referred to these topics.

During the election campaign, the parties paid little attention to other issues, such as health, education and the fight against corruption.

The Serbian Progressive Party was the main party making promises about economic development – 56 per cent of its promises in election campaign were about this issue. On the other hand, the New Democratic Party too the leading position in promises about education, with 33 per cent of all promises about education coming from this party. The Democratic Party made 35 per cent of its promises about public finances, 24 per cent about economic development, 6 per cent about fight against corruption, 11 per cent about health and 24 per cent about education. The fight against corruption was least mentioned by the parties.

BIRN’s web site www.meravlade.rs is an innovative watchdog tool launched in December 2013 which enables people to evaluate to what extent, and in what way, the government has matched the promises that the parties of the ruling coalition made in the election campaign and at the beginning of their term in office.

 

BIRN Serbia Launches Government Performance Report

BIRN Serbia has launched new summary report assessing the overall 2012-14 performance of the Serbian government. The report is published on the website www.meravlade.rs, and examines the electoral promises of the ruling parties, the Serbian Progressives and Socialists, and their fulfillment, as monitored through the entire period of the government that was in office from July 2012 to January 2014.

The report covers the policies position in four areas considered primary concerns by Serbian of citizens: the economy and public finances, the fight against corruption, health and education.

Electoral promises and policy reforms are graded into three categories: ‘complete success’, ‘partial success’ and ‘unfulfilled promise’.

According to BIRN’s monitoring, the least success was achieved in the sector of education, where none of the government’s promises was fulfilled. Mild success was achieved in the area of economy and health, where approximately 10 to 15 per cent electoral promises were graded as a ‘complete success’ and some 60 per cent as a ‘partial success’.

The report shows that the ruling parties had the most success in the fight against corruption, in which five of the seven announced reforms achieved a complete or partial success, with two completely unfulfilled promises.

In December 2013, BIRN Serbia launched a new website, meravlade.rs, the first online platform to provide clear, critical and unbiased insight into the progress of reforms and delivery of public policies, comparing them to the pledges made during the last election campaign.

MeraVlade offers full information on BIRN’s monitoring, along with news, analytical reports and information about the project’s public debates.

Full report in Serbian for download

BIRN Serbia Debates Holes in Patients’ Rights Law

Efficient application of the Law on Protection of Patients’ Rights, problems concerning its application, and the role of local government in appointing councilors for patients’ rights were key topics in the debate, “Law on Protection of Patients’ Rights – law without application?”, organized by BIRN Serbia on December 20.

The debate gathered more than 30 participants from government, independent institutions, local authorities, the NGO sector and the media.

More details about the law are available at: http://www.meravlade.rs/zastita-prava-pacijenata/  

BIRN Serbia organized the debate, aware that some 47 per cent of municipalities had not fully applied the Law on Patients’ Rights and appointed councilors for patients’ rights by a December 1 deadline.

The NGO Serbia on the Move, BIRN Serbia’s partner organization, presented data from its research carried out among 105 municipalities all over the Serbia, which showed that by early December only 42 of them had appointed such councilors and formed Councils for Patients’ Rights.

More details of the debate are available at: http://www.meravlade.rs/odrzana-debata-zastita-prava-pacijenata-zakon-bez-primene-20-12/ 

Dr Ivana Rodic, from the Ministry of Health, outlined the activities of the ministry in regard to the two laws, saying the Ministry had implemented all the steps it needed to take.

Dr Predrag Stojičić, from Serbia on the Move, and Marina Mijatovic, from the NGO Law Scanner, responded that the authorities had left matters far too late, saying that essential communication with citizens and doctors had been left out.

Gordana Stevanović, from the Ombudsman’s office, explained the role of this institution in the process and pointed out both positive and negative sides to the new law. She also presented the Ombudsman’s plan to organize similar debates and round tables to monitor and support the process of patients’ rights protection.

Marija Djordjevic from Kragujevac shared her town’s positive experiences about the provision of patients’ rights protection, in force for some months now already, since the town participated in the pilot project implemented by SCTM (Standing Conference of Towns and Municipalities). She explained how certain procedures were established, where difficulties had occurred and how they were resolved.

In the debate that followed, members of the audience took part, including representatives of the Republican Health Insurance Fund, the municipality of Indjija, and several patients’ associations.

BIRN Serbia will announce and promote a set of recommendations in regard to better implementation of this law and will continue to evaluate trends in the health sector as part of its monitoring project.

New Website by BIRN Serbia

BIRN Serbia invites you to visit our new web portal Mera Vlade at www.meravlade.rs.

Mera Vlade is the first online platform that provides clear, critical and unbiased insight into the progress of reforms and delivery of public policies, comparing them to the pledges made during the last election campaign.

This innovative watchdog tool enables people to evaluate to what extent, and in what way, the government has matched the promises that the parties of the ruling coalition made in the election campaign and at the beginning of their term in office. BIRN Serbia has collected various items of information from the spring 2012 campaign, including statements, programs, election platforms, the Prime Minister’s inaugural speech and the Coalition agreement.

In addition, Mera Vlade monitors the progress of reforms in five key areas that citizens have rated as most important for social development and quality of life: public finances; the economy; the fight against corruption; health; education.

Mera Vlade is intended for the use of all the citizens, but especially for voters, who are now gaining a user-friendly tool to monitor the government’s performance and accountability.

Within this portal, citizens, organizations, and both state and non-state institutions can also follow announcements about our own debates and other events organized within the project, which will review the government’s performance with a special emphasis on promised and implemented measures.

We invite you to contribute to the creation of a clear overview and objective picture of government activities by posting your comments and additional information related to project themes, either directly on the website or through BIRN Serbia.

For more information, contact Tanja Maksić, the project coordinator, at [email protected].

Patients Rights Put Under the Microscope

BIRN Serbia is organizing a public discussion on “Protection of patients’ rights – the law without implementation at the Media Center in Belgrade on Friday, December 20.

The speakers will be Perisa Simonovic, state secretary at the Health Ministry, Gordana Stevanovic, a representative of the ombudsman’s office, Marina Mijatovic, director of the NGO Legal Scanner, Predrag Stojicic, director of Serbia on the Move and representative of the council for patients’ rights in Kragujevac.

From December 1, under the law on the protection of patients’ rights, people have a right to better protection of their rights in the health care system in cooperation with a patients’ rights advisor in their local authorities.

However, a survey by Serbia on the Move shows that some municipalities have not yet appointed such advisers and are delaying implementation of the law on protecting patients’ rights.

The main obstacles in implementing the law, examples of good practice and the responsibilities of each actor in this process are all questions that the debate will cover.

BIRN Serbia in cooperation with NGO Serbia on the Move is organizing the discussion as a part of its monitoring project ‘’Mera Vlade’’.

Within this project, BIRN Serbia has been monitoring government policies in the fields of the economy, health, education and the fight against corruption since 2012.

The project aims to foster a greater degree of political accountability, transparency and efficiency in the implementation of reforms.

BIRN Serbia Holds Fifth National Budget Forum

BIRN Serbia and Pro Concept held their fifth national budget forum at the National Assembly in Belgrade on 27 November, where panelists and participants offered their opinions and debated the proposed 2014 budget and the projected outcomes of the Serbian administration’s budgetary policy.

The panelists were finance minister Lazar Krstic, Pavle Petrovic, president of the Fiscal Council of Serbia, and Mihajlo Babin, assistant at Belgrade University’s faculty of economics, finance and administration.

The budget for next year is realistic and represents the first step towards the normalisation of fiscal policy because it does not make deeper cuts than necessary, said finance minister Krstic.

The minister said that a third of the budget will go to public sector employees, who number more than 740,000. He added that the government will propose a review of public administration employment.

Krstic also announced that there will be a reform of pay scales in the public sector, partly because of the budget deficit.

Responding to a suggestion from the Fiscal Council that reforms should be more aggressive when it comes to pensions, Krstic said that it was not politically possible.

Pavle Petrovic pointed to the need for fiscal consolidation, because without it, crisis is certain, he warned. He added that its aim was not to raise economic growth, but to create the conditions in which growth is possible.

”Necessary measures through which the state can affect economic growth include changes in the labour law, which have been announced but have still not been implemented, the shortening of procedures for construction permits, resolving the fate of companies in restructuring, and reforming public enterprises,” said Petrovic.

He said in 2014 alone, 560 million euro will be spent on unsuccessful public companies such as Srbijagas, Galenika, Serbian Railways, and partly on banks.

According to Petrovic, the biggest problem is Srbijagas with debts of over a billion euro, of which 800 million are owed to banks.

He stressed that it was import ant that from the middle of the next year Srbijagas, as a company which should operate with a profit, does not receive any money from the budget and begins paying off some of its debts by itself.

”Next year Srbijagas will cost 150 million euro, which is more than what is given to Serbian Railways, the company with the largest subsidies so far and more than overall government spending on science. Not only that, but it is more than the planned savings of 100 million euro by introducing a solidarity tax on salaries in the public sector,” said Petrovic.

Mihajlo Babin meanwhile pointed to the problem of ineffective financing of the public sector, as well as the problem of using up loans, with $3 billion of loan funds currently untouched.

”The key question is what the loans are used for, whether for structural reforms or not. Loans are not supposed to be taken up for covering liquidity, but to increase development. In the future, we should solve the problem of how to give up on loans that we do not need. It is better to pay the penalty now , rather than  interest later on, or to start efficiently implementing them in certain sectors,” said Babin.

The fifth national budget forum brought together more than 90 representatives of ministries, local government and civil society.

BIRN Serbia gives investigative reporting master class

BIRN Serbia’s Aleksandar Djordjevic and Slobodan Georgiev took part in a special programme at Belgrade’s political science faculty focused on investigative reporting for students of journalism, and presenting BIRN’s experience in this area.

In the one-hour class, Georgiev and Djordjevic explained main challenges and principles of investigative journalism to the 20 students who attended.

Georgiev spoke about the starting points of every investigation and final goals of a story.

“Investigative journalism lies in every good story and it is not about sending someone to prison, it is about a good journalistic job,” he said.

Djordjevic spoke about several examples that illustrate how these principles work in practice by guiding participants through one investigative process. He presented possible online and offline sources and demonstrated techniques for checking information.